Life hack Duck Tumblr

"Look at All These Ducks There Are at Least Ten." Why Is This Funny?  December 18, 2015 – 05:37 pm

The animated GIF above—along with the caption "Look at all those ducks there are at least ten"—is currently floating around the Internet. The thousands of people who have liked and shared it on various sites, including Tumblr, Reddit, and Imgur, presumably think it's entertaining, but why?

At the risk of spoiling the joke by overanalyzing it, a linguist named Paul Grice has an answer.

What's curious, at first glance, is the contrast between "at least ten ducks" and the vast swarm of ducks in the actual picture. The incongruity of the caption leads to humor, right? But this too is strange. After all, the statement is technically true, as pointed out by the almost-as-popular follow-up comment: "Well, you're not wrong." And sure enough, if we were sorting a series of images into piles of those containing at least ten ducks and those containing nine ducks or fewer, this throng of ducks would no doubt fall into the first group. Why, then, does it sound funny to make—albeit out of the blue—what is undeniably a true assertion? Is it simple understatement, or is there something more at work?

Here's where Paul Grice comes in. Grice was the first to describe some of the implicit assumptions that everyone makes in conversation, known as Gricean Maxims in his honor. In particular, he noted that everything that someone says is interpreted as if it were relevant to the circumstances and what had been said before. It sounds simple, but it's something that computers, compared to humans at least, are surprisingly bad at.

Take the following exchange, for example:

Speaker 1: "Would you like some coffee?"
Speaker 2: "Coffee would keep me awake."

Speaker 1 could reasonably interpret that answer as a yes or a no depending on the context. If it's morning and there's work to be done, being kept awake is likely desirable, but if it's late evening, well, probably not. It all hinges on what is the most relevant interpretation: The yes or no isn't inherent to the answer itself, but you figure it out, without much thought, based on your common-sense knowledge of the world, referred to in linguistics as your pragmatic competence.

Grice and his successors break this idea down further. In general, we assume that people are truthful, that they are giving as much detail as is pertinent and no more, and that they're being as clear as possible. When someone seems to be violating one of these assumptions, it's logical to deduce that they're doing so for a particular reason, such as biting sarcasm or, in the case of our ducks, for laughs.


You might also like:

DIY Room Decor Life Hacks: Easy Tumblr DIY Ideas!
DIY Room Decor Life Hacks: Easy Tumblr DIY Ideas!
DIY Tumblr Room Decor + Fall Life Hacks! | Meredith Foster
DIY Tumblr Room Decor + Fall Life Hacks! | Meredith Foster
Tumblr and truTV Are Going to Make a Show About Life Hacks
Tumblr and truTV Are Going to Make a Show About Life Hacks
  • avatar Life Hacks DIY Duck Ear Buds
    • When the duck is drawn you want to cut out the duck drawing.

Related posts:

  1. Sims life Hacks Tumblr
  2. Life Hacks parody Tumblr
  3. Life Hacks Tumblr 99
  4. Life Hacks funny Tumblr
  5. Life Hacks to school